Science Integration Institute logo
Archived E-mail Discussion List

 

Home

About Us

Resources

Bookstore

Education

Support SII

Research

Contact Us

Return to E-mail Discussion page

> evolution - a recent scientific american article claimed that
> darwin had the greatest influence on scientific thinking in
> the world of any scientist in the last [some large number i
> forget of] years. survival of the fittest might be easily
> incorporated because its so simple (to the point of some large
> inaccuracies, i suspect?) and familiar in ordinary life.

I once heard an interesting comment about the spread of "evolution" to other fields. It was argued that it was *too* powerful of an idea, that too many fields were taking evolution as a metaphor to explain ideas in their own fields that may not be relevant. For example, people taking evolution & natural selection and applying it to morality, and coming up with social Darwinism. But the argument was that this over-application of evolution also occured in other fields of knowlege, with the implication that it was mis-used. I don't know if this is really a problem or if the argument was coming from someone who just plain didn't like evolution.

A possible counter-example is the idea of "catastrophe theory" that was originally developed in physics & math. This theory is no longer in favor in the physics community, but as a metaphor it has been quite useful to the social sciences, I think.
So, I guess my point is that intringuing scientific ideas can be used & misused in ways that may have little to do with the actual scientific value/purpose of the ideas in their original context. This is true both for other fields of knowlege, and for society.

--Eric

Food for thought:

"Regardless of different personal views about science, no credible understanding of the natural world or our human existence…can ignore the basic insights of theories as key as evolution, relativity, and quantum mechanics." - The Dalai Lama
Send comments and suggestions to: © 1998-2009 Science Integration Institute
  info@scienceintegration.org Last Modified: March 31, 2005