Science Integration Institute logo
Archived E-mail Discussion List

 

Home

About Us

Resources

Bookstore

Education

Support SII

Research

Contact Us

Return to E-mail Discussion page

Next in thread

I have found a very simple example that everybody can understand but that at the same time can resolve a fundamental problem. One should only see fig. 6-7 on p. 112 in W. Panofsky, M. Phillips, Classical Electricity and Magnetism, 2nd ed., Addison-Wesley, 1962 (or fig. 6-7 on p. 102 in the 1st ed.). As a pair of (vertical) capacitor plates partially dip into a dielectric liquid, the liquid inside the capacitor is shown to rise high above the surface of the liquid that is outside the capacitor. Four hypotheses seem relevant:

1. Panofsky gives a wrong picture - the effect does not exist.
2. If we punch a hole in the plate, below the surface of the liquid inside the capacitor but above the surface of the liquid outside the capacitor, no liquid will leak out through the hole.
3. The liquid will leak out in violation of the first law.
4. The liquid will leak out in violation of the second law.

I think the 4th hypothesis is correct.

Best regards,
Pentcho

Food for thought:

"Regardless of different personal views about science, no credible understanding of the natural world or our human existence…can ignore the basic insights of theories as key as evolution, relativity, and quantum mechanics." - The Dalai Lama
Send comments and suggestions to: © 1998-2009 Science Integration Institute
  info@scienceintegration.org Last Modified: August 4, 2006